Mayor's Weekly Message

Independent report refutes ‘super council’ myths

20 Sep 2013

The director of the Centre for Local Government at the University of New England, Professor Brian Dollery, wrote in the Sydney Morning Herald this week that current proposals to amalgamate Manly and Pittwater Councils with Warringah Council could cost “tens of millions of dollars” creating “a new and entirely unnecessary layer of local government that duplicates existing arrangements in many respects.”

Professor Dollery is the author of a new report revealing that larger Councils are not necessarily better for residents and ratepayers - and that forced amalgamations in particular do not improve financial sustainability or customer experience.

Warringah Council is aiming to amalgamate the three Northern Beaches Councils and perhaps to expand that into an even wider merger with Ku-ring-gai, Hornsby and Mosman Councils!

Forced amalgamations of that kind could cost ratepayers another $2 million a year in charges according to independent research - and could even lead to a widening of socio-economic differences between local council areas.

The merger proposed by Warringah Council is not viable for several key reasons, including:

  • There is no 'community of interest' between Manly, Warringah and Pittwater Councils considered essential for an amalgamation to occur successfully
  • Associated ‘local boards’ being proposed by the Independent Local Government Review Panel to retain ‘local representation’ within a ‘super council’ are both expensive and inappropriate for New South Wales
  • Amalgamation does not improve financial sustainability and would in the short-term increase costs to ratepayers substantially and, in any case,
  • No economies of scale are present in the amalgamation options being proposed by Warringah Council!

The NSW Local Government Act already allows for effective co-governance structures and that numerous examples of effective co-governance of this kind already operate in NSW.

Both Manly and Pittwater intend continuing to save residents costs through SHOROC and other such structures.

Pittwater Mayor Jacqui Townsend and I will be writing to the State Government on behalf of our respective communities objecting to any forced amalgamations of the type proposed by Warringah Council.

Jean Hay AM

Back to listing